The BFRO team goes to Rhode Island, to prove that while the state may be small, it can still have Bigfoot. They're surprised that Rhode Island has so much trackless forest (Hint: All of New England does.), and they've come to check out some supposed footage. Most of the team thinks the blurry object in the film could be sasquatch, but Ranae (wisely) points out that the story behind this (footage for documentary) is fishy. Plus, the blurry image could be someone in a coat. "Why do you have to think it's a bigfoot?" Ranae asks. Why, indeed? A recreation indicates the "figure" is smaller than Bobo, and to me it looks like it could even be a shadow of a tree, though a person in a hoodie seems more likely than Bobo's juvenile sasquatch suggestion. They do a night hunt complete with calling; coyotes reply, and they hear mysterious squatchy "knocks." This time, they leave Cliff behind in the woods to look around more while the rest go and hear the usual interesting stories from local folks. (Though the team is surprised that Rhode Island has so many stories, I guess 'cause the state is so small.)
This time, one of the witnesses even has a actual track (cut from the dirt) and a cast of what he found, though he didn't actually see what made the prints. Ranae recreates the print's stride, and suggests that the print may have been someone in those barefoot/glove jogging shoes. Naturally, Matt and Bobo still believe it was a squatch. Cliff, meanwhile, finds animal tracks and hears barn owls (which he readily identifies; points for that). Joining back up, the group decides to do a night hunt trying to flush any animals toward Ranae, who's observing from a tree stand. But aside from small fauna, they turn up nothing. Bobo, of course, thinks he heard something and declares Rhode Island "Squatchy as hell." Well, maybe if Hell has lots of stories by no actual sasquatch. Sorry, guys, blurry footage, colorful stories, and no actual evidence do not a bigfoot make.