History Channel - 12/10/08
What was seen in the skies over Phoenix Arizona on the night of March 13, 1997? Is it something alien, or a top secret government project? That night, thousands of witnesses saw a wedge-like shape of bright lights hovering "over" the city. Earlier in the night, a boomerang-shaped craft was seen over other parts of the state -- sometimes hovering, sometimes moving at incredible speeds. The craft was said to be up to a mile wide. Though witnesses claim the lights were otherworldly, the government says they were flares dropped by the Maryland National Guard (see Lights Over Phoenix in a previous review). A councilwoman who suggested an investigation was ridiculed and harassed. The state governor seemed about to look into it, and then brought out a man in an alien costume for a press conference, setting off more laughter and derision. The night in question, a witness described the lights coming on in an arc, and then going out in the same order they came on in. He says they look nothing like the flares he'd seen before. He thinks they could have been 1) a hoax, 2) an alien craft (which he says unlikely), or 3) a military experiment. Expert Ted plans to test the military's flare explanation.
A psychiatrist says that she'd seen such lights before in the months leading up to the sighting. She describes the events that night as not flickering like flares, but "orbs." Another witness and his wife first saw lights on the 10th of March. They do not believe they're flares, either. Ted explains that flares may look different under different atmospheric conditions. He sets up a test using maritime parachute flares off of Longbeach, CA. The witnesses say Ted's flares look different from what they saw -- the other lights hovered. (This fact was disproved by Lights Over Phoenix; the lights did move, and eventually disappeared behind the mountains.) The crew then goes on to interview witnesses of the boomerang-shaped craft with five lights. One witness describes a huge, black shape with an undulating surface, which the show then recreates with CGI. The show then digresses to try to compare the 1997 sightings to local petroglyphs, 1000 years old -- though crew members point out the symbols on the rocks could as easily be stars (or something else) as UFOs. They then talk to a scientist/researcher/article writer who says there are some triangular rigid-hull experimental airships (as big as a football field) in experimental use by the military. They may have been developed for special forces ops, and no pictures exist -- nor will such craft be revealed while they present an advantage to our military.
An interview with the former governor reveals that he was concerned about the intensity of interest in the event, and set up the "alien" interview spoof to defuse the situation. He tried too look into the incident, but got a "no comment" from the air force (which the show takes as an admission that something was there). In an earlier interview, he also admitted that he saw the strange huge craft on the night in question. He describes it as "otherworldly." The crew of the show is split whether the craft is alien or conventional but secret. The show seems to conclude that the lights could not have been flares. Personally, I think the UH crew should have done better research on this point, or at least watched UFOS Over Phoenix.
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query phoenix lights. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query phoenix lights. Sort by date Show all posts
Friday, December 12, 2008
Thursday, July 22, 2010
FACT OR FAKED - Burning Rubber; Hyperjump (Series Premier)
SyFy - Original Air Date: 7/15/10
"Former FBI Agent" Ben Hanson leads a team of investigators (including Jael from Destination Truth) and experts as they evaluate footage sent to them and try to determined whether its Fact or Faked. The show starts with the group gathered together looking at weird footage: shadow figures in the woods and a bedroom, an alien in someone's bedroom, and figuring out which bears more investigation. In this part of the show, the group shows some good critical thinking skills, dismissing some as manipulated, others as possible puppets, and finally zeroing in on two cases: one where a car seems to drive right through a fence to escape a pursuing cop in Georgia, and another of mysterious lights over Arizona. The group splits into two teams and goes to investigate. The "ghost car" team checks with witnesses, finds the scene of the chase, and then recreates it -- at each step, ruling out paranormal happenings (such as the car moving amazingly fast). Finally, they set up some scenarios for driving "through" the fence. They do manage to jump a car over the fence, but not without damage. Then they hit on the idea of loosening some of the fence fasteners -- which the officer reported during the case. Doing that allows a speeding car to drive right through; the fence flexes and then swings back down, perfectly intact -- just in time to foil the pursuing cop. One very lucky perp.
The second segment deals with lights appearing at dusk over an Arizona mountain range. While these lights look to me like the Phoenix Lights, which UFOs Over Phoenix conclusively proved to be military flares, the crew dismisses the flare theory. They play some flare footage which does not look comparable (though it's the wrong angle and distance), and the witness says the Air Force said they weren't dropping flares on the night in question. Sadly, the team does not seem to call the military to double check that (and we know that the military sometimes makes mistakes in such cases, or denies "secret" flights). They then try to recreate the lights using lasers reflected off of glass and lights attached to balloons. Their results, while interesting, do not match the video. They then set up night cameras and poke around in the dark for a while (seemingly required for any investigation show - though conducting ground searches at night seems like a foolish idea to me). And they do catch some "strange lights" in the sky on video. Though one looks like an atmospheric phenomenon to me, several others are genuinely odd. Unfortunately, the program doesn't show enough of the footage surrounding the sightings to get a proper context. Mysterious, yes, but certainly not the lights they were investigating. Calling in an aviation or space expert would seem to be in order, but they don't do it. They claim the footage supports the idea of new UFO sightings over Phoenix. (Note that UFOs are merely unidentified, not "aliens.")
To me, though, the original footage -- which the program never seems to show enough of to gain proper context -- looks like a "string" of flares being dropped, lighting up, and then going out one by one in the order they were dropped. If not the military, it could have even been fireworks dropped by a private plane as a prank. I have no evidence for this, but my scenarios (military or private) seem a far more reasonable explanation than the "hyperjump" being claimed for the mystery lights.
My fear with this show -- and other shows in the paranormal investigation genre -- is that we'll get results that are skewed away from science and toward retaining viewers every week. (I've seen similar problems in MonsterQuest, Ghost Hunters, and other programs.) Viewers want to believe, and they may get bored with "we found nothing unusual" week after week. Thus, I am concerned that each week on this program we may get one debunked case, and one "real" case -- and on the "real" case, the team will just stop looking/investigating/probing before they should. It would be nice if this show were the Mythbusters of the paranormal. Instead, it's likely to be more like Destination Truth without the interesting personalities.
Wednesday, July 16, 2008
UFO: The Best Evidence Ever (Caught on Tape)
Fox Reality Channel - Original Air Date: 1997
This review will be long, due to the number of clips in the program.
This show purports to show genuine UFO films showing unknown craft, either military or alien. It begins with the Phoenix lights, showing the footage that has been proved (in UFOs Over Phoenix) to be military flares. Despite this, the show presents animations showing the "object" to be over a mile wide. The show then moves on to a glowing ball of light reportedly over Area 51. Then there's a very hokey looking tape supposedly showing a UFO changing shape and making "impossible" maneuvers, again from Area 51. (It looks clearly fake to me -- and the "shape changing" takes place during cuts.) Then we move onto Gulf Breeze, with photos and videos -- including one which is clearly a bug moving by the camera, and a ball turning into a silver streak that could be a bead of water (or mercury) on glass. A cylinder-shaped object is more convincing, but is followed by another "Christmas tree" shaped craft Gulf Breeze photo taken by the same witness. (For me, one filmed encounter could be chance; two seems more likely a hoax. If it were that easy, how come scientists and news crews can't do it?)
A film from Ecuador (1995) seems to show a flying object with rotating lights, like a "glowing chandelier." (One expert opines that it could be a miniature.) In 1990, a Brazilian craft seems to flash strange patterns in the sky. In 1990, formations of UFOs were photographed above an East German nuclear plant. Despite multiple angles, it's still impossible to figure out what the objects are (they look like flares). But if they were there for hours, why isn't there better film? A Mexican film seems to show a UFO following a formation of jets. A similar helicopter sighting looks more like a bright star and video error to me. The show then shows some NASA footage, including 1969 moon landing "orbs" -- which NASA (rightly) contends are reflections. See the recent review of NASA on UFO Hunters, which also debunked the next clip in this show, for more info.
Next, we see the debunked crop circle formation video (Is It Real? Crop Circles), and a supposed landing in West Carlton, Canada reported by "Guardian." As usual, the show's "expert" thinks the landing is not a hoax; an RCMP spokesman believes it is merely a helicopter. At least the show's experts figure out the crop circle film to be a hoax. Another Gulf Breeze film seems to me to show a reflection, though "experts" claim it is a disc that accelerated at amazing speed. Following this, a Miami film shows a glowing UFO, but despite the expert's opinion that this is real, this film is clearly a fake done with reflections. A Juarez Mexico film UFO seems saucer shaped, but displays similar lights to aircraft -- which, indeed is what they prove to be: blimps, as is a similar film from NY.
We move on to the mass sightings in 1991 Mexico. These films, though intriguing, have been proven to be stars or other normal objects distorted by camera artifacts -- but not by this show, which declares them all real. Another Mexican video hound specializes in photographing UFOs near airplanes, apparently generating fear in pilots -- but not enough interest for Mexican authorities to follow the photographer and find out how he has so many sightings. Is a video of 24 lights in formation trying to send us a message? (Is the message that the objects are birds?) The show then goes on to trash the Air Force's "final report" on Roswell and all other government UFO cover-ups. Amazingly, the show then ends with Jonathan Frakes (the narrator) pleading that people not make hoaxes for profit, to gain attention, or for kicks. Yet, with shows like this egging them on, hoaxers are getting better all the time.
This show is an exemplar of what is wrong with the "science" of UFO investigation; too many people with no knowledge of optics or stagecraft who, in the words of the X-Files, "want to believe." As a result, we get a lot of bogus tapes quickly declared genuine -- and then never refuted. Until the UFO-hunting community is willing to declare a fake a fake, they have no chance of ever being taken seriously by science. And it should be no surprise when science asks these so-called researchers, "Is this the best you've got?" If you want to see pretty UFO pictures, this is the show for you. But don't believe one second of it.
This review will be long, due to the number of clips in the program.
This show purports to show genuine UFO films showing unknown craft, either military or alien. It begins with the Phoenix lights, showing the footage that has been proved (in UFOs Over Phoenix) to be military flares. Despite this, the show presents animations showing the "object" to be over a mile wide. The show then moves on to a glowing ball of light reportedly over Area 51. Then there's a very hokey looking tape supposedly showing a UFO changing shape and making "impossible" maneuvers, again from Area 51. (It looks clearly fake to me -- and the "shape changing" takes place during cuts.) Then we move onto Gulf Breeze, with photos and videos -- including one which is clearly a bug moving by the camera, and a ball turning into a silver streak that could be a bead of water (or mercury) on glass. A cylinder-shaped object is more convincing, but is followed by another "Christmas tree" shaped craft Gulf Breeze photo taken by the same witness. (For me, one filmed encounter could be chance; two seems more likely a hoax. If it were that easy, how come scientists and news crews can't do it?)
A film from Ecuador (1995) seems to show a flying object with rotating lights, like a "glowing chandelier." (One expert opines that it could be a miniature.) In 1990, a Brazilian craft seems to flash strange patterns in the sky. In 1990, formations of UFOs were photographed above an East German nuclear plant. Despite multiple angles, it's still impossible to figure out what the objects are (they look like flares). But if they were there for hours, why isn't there better film? A Mexican film seems to show a UFO following a formation of jets. A similar helicopter sighting looks more like a bright star and video error to me. The show then shows some NASA footage, including 1969 moon landing "orbs" -- which NASA (rightly) contends are reflections. See the recent review of NASA on UFO Hunters, which also debunked the next clip in this show, for more info.
Next, we see the debunked crop circle formation video (Is It Real? Crop Circles), and a supposed landing in West Carlton, Canada reported by "Guardian." As usual, the show's "expert" thinks the landing is not a hoax; an RCMP spokesman believes it is merely a helicopter. At least the show's experts figure out the crop circle film to be a hoax. Another Gulf Breeze film seems to me to show a reflection, though "experts" claim it is a disc that accelerated at amazing speed. Following this, a Miami film shows a glowing UFO, but despite the expert's opinion that this is real, this film is clearly a fake done with reflections. A Juarez Mexico film UFO seems saucer shaped, but displays similar lights to aircraft -- which, indeed is what they prove to be: blimps, as is a similar film from NY.
We move on to the mass sightings in 1991 Mexico. These films, though intriguing, have been proven to be stars or other normal objects distorted by camera artifacts -- but not by this show, which declares them all real. Another Mexican video hound specializes in photographing UFOs near airplanes, apparently generating fear in pilots -- but not enough interest for Mexican authorities to follow the photographer and find out how he has so many sightings. Is a video of 24 lights in formation trying to send us a message? (Is the message that the objects are birds?) The show then goes on to trash the Air Force's "final report" on Roswell and all other government UFO cover-ups. Amazingly, the show then ends with Jonathan Frakes (the narrator) pleading that people not make hoaxes for profit, to gain attention, or for kicks. Yet, with shows like this egging them on, hoaxers are getting better all the time.
This show is an exemplar of what is wrong with the "science" of UFO investigation; too many people with no knowledge of optics or stagecraft who, in the words of the X-Files, "want to believe." As a result, we get a lot of bogus tapes quickly declared genuine -- and then never refuted. Until the UFO-hunting community is willing to declare a fake a fake, they have no chance of ever being taken seriously by science. And it should be no surprise when science asks these so-called researchers, "Is this the best you've got?" If you want to see pretty UFO pictures, this is the show for you. But don't believe one second of it.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009
I Know What I Saw
History Channel - Original Air Date: September, 2009
This show brings together eyewitness reports of UFOs -- supposedly the most compelling accounts available. James Fox starts his documentary with the Phoenix lights, which doesn't help with credibility in my book, as the major event of that night (the lights over the city) have been convincingly debunked. (See my partial review of UFOs Over Phoenix.) He then states that 95% of this stuff is crazy, but it's the other stuff that interests him. I agree, and like the Mayor of Phoenix, I agree that the craziness makes it difficult to take a serious look at what's going on. Fox then shows the famous Phoenix footage, and notes that some experts have said it is flares -- but what was the earlier, "boomerang-shaped" craft? There is some shaky footage, and some footage of something similar, but no one knows what it is. (If I had to guess, I'd say secret military aircraft -- but, then, I don't believe in aliens from outer or inner space.) Clips of a National Press Club briefing featuring experts -- many aviators or ex-military -- follow. After that, we get some history of sightings from Foo Fighters, to Kenneth Arnold, to the Washington DC flap, the Life magazine article, Dr. Hynek, and so on. The show also features numerous famous photos, at least a few of which look like natural phenomena or fakes to me. The show also goes to a DC meeting of UFO witnesses to collect some more stories.
Next, an expert on symbols looks at some witness drawings of symbols seen on UFOs, but Fox admits his interpretation is merely speculation -- though the symbols do look something like the Voyager glyphs we sent to the edge of the solar system. The show then looks at the US air base in England reports (Rendlesham Forest) from 1980. And then Japanese flight 1628, which encountered a UFO in 1986. From there, we go to Fox's appearance on CNN, during this DC conference -- in which a skeptic suggests that UFOs are modern mythology. Fox asks where the myths come from, and then plays clips of the media ridiculing UFO witnesses (one of whom is Congressman Dennis Kucinich). Fox follows this with clips of more witnesses, including a former Belgian Air Force commander, and more pilots. Fox's point seems to be that the witnesses aren't as silly as portrayed in the media. Indeed, the ones he trots out all seem very reasonable and credible (but that doesn't mean the UFOs are space aliens). Moving to the Stephenville sightings (type Stephenville into the search bar of www.howlsandgrowls.com for related stories), where Angela Joiner, reporter, notes that if something of the reported size moved at the reported speed, it would leave a sonic footprint on the ground like a tornado. So, how could that be? Fox says he has no idea, and then interviews more witnesses, one of whom claims to have studied the craft at close range through a rifle scope for 3 minutes, before it disappeared. Fox then shows a radar image of something in the area accelerating to 532 MPH in 30 seconds (not an absurd speed). The miliatary denies any knowledge (big surprise).
Astronaut Gordon Cooper (Mercury program) claims to have seen a UFO when station at Edwards AFB. While filming (?!) a precision landing, they sighted a saucer which landed on 3 legs and was filmed before taking off. Cooper claims the film was sent to Washington and never seen again. Cooper claims to have had no contact with anyone involved in the intervening years, not even the cameramen. (Why not?) Astronaut Edgar Mitchell (Apollo program) claims to have talked to many people about flying craft, but doesn't know why investigators are being stonewalled. Former President Carter is next on the hit list, but when asked about what he was told when President, he says "Nobody knows or has proof of things." The show then (pointlessly) speculates why UFO info would be covered up. Fox then meets with a French general and gets even more stories, and a UFO picture accidentally taken by a "mapping camera." The French think the best explanation is that these objects are extraterrestrial in origin. France has since posted all its UFO files online; the release doesn't seem to have caused any panic. More speculation ensues, including the supposition that UFOs must be "real" because there are so many sightings. But, while seeing may be believing, seeing is not scientific proof.
Sadly, in the end, these stories -- however compelling -- are just stories. The fact that credible people say them doesn't make them true, and, even if they are true, it doesn't mean that their perceptions are not leading the witnesses astray. Certainly, people see strange things -- from UFOs to ghosts to goblins to the Loch Ness Monster -- and maybe someday we'll understand what these things are, or at least why we see them. Stories, though, are not proof. You can take that from me, as someone who's made a living by telling stories for most of my adult life. But, by all means, we should keep looking and keep investigating -- scientifically.
This show brings together eyewitness reports of UFOs -- supposedly the most compelling accounts available. James Fox starts his documentary with the Phoenix lights, which doesn't help with credibility in my book, as the major event of that night (the lights over the city) have been convincingly debunked. (See my partial review of UFOs Over Phoenix.) He then states that 95% of this stuff is crazy, but it's the other stuff that interests him. I agree, and like the Mayor of Phoenix, I agree that the craziness makes it difficult to take a serious look at what's going on. Fox then shows the famous Phoenix footage, and notes that some experts have said it is flares -- but what was the earlier, "boomerang-shaped" craft? There is some shaky footage, and some footage of something similar, but no one knows what it is. (If I had to guess, I'd say secret military aircraft -- but, then, I don't believe in aliens from outer or inner space.) Clips of a National Press Club briefing featuring experts -- many aviators or ex-military -- follow. After that, we get some history of sightings from Foo Fighters, to Kenneth Arnold, to the Washington DC flap, the Life magazine article, Dr. Hynek, and so on. The show also features numerous famous photos, at least a few of which look like natural phenomena or fakes to me. The show also goes to a DC meeting of UFO witnesses to collect some more stories.
Next, an expert on symbols looks at some witness drawings of symbols seen on UFOs, but Fox admits his interpretation is merely speculation -- though the symbols do look something like the Voyager glyphs we sent to the edge of the solar system. The show then looks at the US air base in England reports (Rendlesham Forest) from 1980. And then Japanese flight 1628, which encountered a UFO in 1986. From there, we go to Fox's appearance on CNN, during this DC conference -- in which a skeptic suggests that UFOs are modern mythology. Fox asks where the myths come from, and then plays clips of the media ridiculing UFO witnesses (one of whom is Congressman Dennis Kucinich). Fox follows this with clips of more witnesses, including a former Belgian Air Force commander, and more pilots. Fox's point seems to be that the witnesses aren't as silly as portrayed in the media. Indeed, the ones he trots out all seem very reasonable and credible (but that doesn't mean the UFOs are space aliens). Moving to the Stephenville sightings (type Stephenville into the search bar of www.howlsandgrowls.com for related stories), where Angela Joiner, reporter, notes that if something of the reported size moved at the reported speed, it would leave a sonic footprint on the ground like a tornado. So, how could that be? Fox says he has no idea, and then interviews more witnesses, one of whom claims to have studied the craft at close range through a rifle scope for 3 minutes, before it disappeared. Fox then shows a radar image of something in the area accelerating to 532 MPH in 30 seconds (not an absurd speed). The miliatary denies any knowledge (big surprise).
Astronaut Gordon Cooper (Mercury program) claims to have seen a UFO when station at Edwards AFB. While filming (?!) a precision landing, they sighted a saucer which landed on 3 legs and was filmed before taking off. Cooper claims the film was sent to Washington and never seen again. Cooper claims to have had no contact with anyone involved in the intervening years, not even the cameramen. (Why not?) Astronaut Edgar Mitchell (Apollo program) claims to have talked to many people about flying craft, but doesn't know why investigators are being stonewalled. Former President Carter is next on the hit list, but when asked about what he was told when President, he says "Nobody knows or has proof of things." The show then (pointlessly) speculates why UFO info would be covered up. Fox then meets with a French general and gets even more stories, and a UFO picture accidentally taken by a "mapping camera." The French think the best explanation is that these objects are extraterrestrial in origin. France has since posted all its UFO files online; the release doesn't seem to have caused any panic. More speculation ensues, including the supposition that UFOs must be "real" because there are so many sightings. But, while seeing may be believing, seeing is not scientific proof.
Sadly, in the end, these stories -- however compelling -- are just stories. The fact that credible people say them doesn't make them true, and, even if they are true, it doesn't mean that their perceptions are not leading the witnesses astray. Certainly, people see strange things -- from UFOs to ghosts to goblins to the Loch Ness Monster -- and maybe someday we'll understand what these things are, or at least why we see them. Stories, though, are not proof. You can take that from me, as someone who's made a living by telling stories for most of my adult life. But, by all means, we should keep looking and keep investigating -- scientifically.
Friday, February 22, 2008
UFOS OVER PHOENIX - Partial Review
Discovery Channel - Original Air Date: 1997?
I just caught a few minutes of this recently, though I've seen the full show in the past. The part I saw that's worth noting is the show's dramatic and convincing explanation for the 10pm (I believe) set of Phoenix Lights: they were flares. UFOlogists reject this idea out of hand, but the show has a demonstration that the "winking out" of the lights coincides with them disappearing behind a mountain range. This is accomplished by aligning the original "UFO" footage with daytime footage taken in the same spot. You can literally see the lights going behind the mountain--which means they weren't over the city, but were on the other side of the range, where the military was conducting exercises (and dropping flares). I don't remember whether the show had an explanation for the earlier sightings of V-shaped craft (probably not), but the footage you always see of this incident -- on Larry King, for instance -- is definitely flares. UFOlogists don't do themselves any favors when they ignore conclusive proof like this; it makes them look like kooks. It also wastes time and resources that could be spent on investigating actual, unexplained incidents.
I just caught a few minutes of this recently, though I've seen the full show in the past. The part I saw that's worth noting is the show's dramatic and convincing explanation for the 10pm (I believe) set of Phoenix Lights: they were flares. UFOlogists reject this idea out of hand, but the show has a demonstration that the "winking out" of the lights coincides with them disappearing behind a mountain range. This is accomplished by aligning the original "UFO" footage with daytime footage taken in the same spot. You can literally see the lights going behind the mountain--which means they weren't over the city, but were on the other side of the range, where the military was conducting exercises (and dropping flares). I don't remember whether the show had an explanation for the earlier sightings of V-shaped craft (probably not), but the footage you always see of this incident -- on Larry King, for instance -- is definitely flares. UFOlogists don't do themselves any favors when they ignore conclusive proof like this; it makes them look like kooks. It also wastes time and resources that could be spent on investigating actual, unexplained incidents.
Saturday, November 7, 2009
UFO HUNTERS - Dark Presence
History Channel - Original Air Date: 10/29/09
According to Bill, UFO reports of orbs are increasing worldwide. The show plays some video, but it's the usual blurry lights in the sky -- and some seem to behave like flares. A guest investigator, Ted, rules out "earth lights" because of the duration of some sightings at "Site X." He believes the orbs can harm plants, livestock, and perhaps even people. He also thinks they have malicious intent. The team gets the usual type of witness stories from cops and other people. They bring in a UFO light expert, who opines that some video is not flares or other known lights. From Phoenix, they go to Kokomo, IN, for more orb reports. A MUFOn member says orange balls of light (OBOL) have been seen for years; he believes the balls are intelligent. A witness describes seeing orbs and then having them haunt her dreams. The group and a local paranormal group set up IR cameras to try and catch something - theorizing orbs give of IR and therefore may be attracted by it. (?!) They claim to have caught "orbs from the spirit realm" with this technique previously. (Seeing their examples, I think they need to become better acquainted with the limitations and quirks of their photographic systems; which is to say, I ain't buying.) But all they find during this stakeout is dust, stars, and aircraft. No surprise there.
After gathering many stories, the UFO-H team goes to Phoenix for more poking around. A woman named Christine believes orbs are dark presences that lurk around archeological sites; she's photographed some. But her "orb" photo in a thunderstorm looks like another camera glitch to me - probably some kind of reflection. She also claims to have heard voices when she saw an orb. (For me, this does not add to her credibility.) She woke up on her couch, believing it to be a dream until a neighbor reported seeing the same thing. Jeff Willis feels he has a relationship with the orbs he photographs; the show describes him as one fo the best known UFO videographers in the US. But his orb photos look like flares and balloons (as in the Mexico hoax -- see UFOs Over Earth), to me; I find anyone with such frequent encounters suspicious. When Jeff's footage is analyzed, the "expert" thinks that some lights are generated by a single triangular craft; but the analysis makes me doubt this "expert's" objectivity and expertise. He suggests connecting the orbs to local petroglyphs. They head out with the publisher of Ancient Times -- which sounds like another pseudo-science magazine -- to look for connections at local ruins. This "expert's" analysis of the glyphs quickly convinces me that he knows little of archeology or art history; he seems just another buff of the supernatural, looking for science to hang his theories on. He believes the orbs are extra terrestrials and were misinterpreted as divine by the native Americans.
Kevin points out that there are a lot of theories here, but no science; he hopes that in the next 50 years, we may figure out this phenomena. He explains the increase of videos and pictures because of the increase of people having cameras with them (as in phones). Bill concludes that events are "quickening," and we had better shape up and pay attention or face the consequences.
One of the consequences, it seems, might be the cancellation of this show (see note about the "wrap up" in the "Area 52" episode). If this is the end, I suspect it will be because week after week, this show has presented very similar stories but very little actual evidence or investigation. Ghost Hunters is pretty much the same from week to week, but at least they have a set of pseudo-scientific standards that they apply to the evidence they gather -- rather than just jumping to the wildest conclusions, which has been this show's forte. Though I signed a petition to save it, I won't be surprised if UFO Hunters has crashed (somewhere near Roswell) at last.
According to Bill, UFO reports of orbs are increasing worldwide. The show plays some video, but it's the usual blurry lights in the sky -- and some seem to behave like flares. A guest investigator, Ted, rules out "earth lights" because of the duration of some sightings at "Site X." He believes the orbs can harm plants, livestock, and perhaps even people. He also thinks they have malicious intent. The team gets the usual type of witness stories from cops and other people. They bring in a UFO light expert, who opines that some video is not flares or other known lights. From Phoenix, they go to Kokomo, IN, for more orb reports. A MUFOn member says orange balls of light (OBOL) have been seen for years; he believes the balls are intelligent. A witness describes seeing orbs and then having them haunt her dreams. The group and a local paranormal group set up IR cameras to try and catch something - theorizing orbs give of IR and therefore may be attracted by it. (?!) They claim to have caught "orbs from the spirit realm" with this technique previously. (Seeing their examples, I think they need to become better acquainted with the limitations and quirks of their photographic systems; which is to say, I ain't buying.) But all they find during this stakeout is dust, stars, and aircraft. No surprise there.
After gathering many stories, the UFO-H team goes to Phoenix for more poking around. A woman named Christine believes orbs are dark presences that lurk around archeological sites; she's photographed some. But her "orb" photo in a thunderstorm looks like another camera glitch to me - probably some kind of reflection. She also claims to have heard voices when she saw an orb. (For me, this does not add to her credibility.) She woke up on her couch, believing it to be a dream until a neighbor reported seeing the same thing. Jeff Willis feels he has a relationship with the orbs he photographs; the show describes him as one fo the best known UFO videographers in the US. But his orb photos look like flares and balloons (as in the Mexico hoax -- see UFOs Over Earth), to me; I find anyone with such frequent encounters suspicious. When Jeff's footage is analyzed, the "expert" thinks that some lights are generated by a single triangular craft; but the analysis makes me doubt this "expert's" objectivity and expertise. He suggests connecting the orbs to local petroglyphs. They head out with the publisher of Ancient Times -- which sounds like another pseudo-science magazine -- to look for connections at local ruins. This "expert's" analysis of the glyphs quickly convinces me that he knows little of archeology or art history; he seems just another buff of the supernatural, looking for science to hang his theories on. He believes the orbs are extra terrestrials and were misinterpreted as divine by the native Americans.
Kevin points out that there are a lot of theories here, but no science; he hopes that in the next 50 years, we may figure out this phenomena. He explains the increase of videos and pictures because of the increase of people having cameras with them (as in phones). Bill concludes that events are "quickening," and we had better shape up and pay attention or face the consequences.
One of the consequences, it seems, might be the cancellation of this show (see note about the "wrap up" in the "Area 52" episode). If this is the end, I suspect it will be because week after week, this show has presented very similar stories but very little actual evidence or investigation. Ghost Hunters is pretty much the same from week to week, but at least they have a set of pseudo-scientific standards that they apply to the evidence they gather -- rather than just jumping to the wildest conclusions, which has been this show's forte. Though I signed a petition to save it, I won't be surprised if UFO Hunters has crashed (somewhere near Roswell) at last.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
